The following is a list of those who have served God by serving NDCC as Pastor:
| Rev. Charles P. Marshall | 1899 - 1900 |
| Rev. R. G. Harbutt | 1900 - 1901 |
| Rev. J. A. Waterworth | 1902 - 1904 |
| Rev. Irving A. Flint and Rev. Inez Randall | 1907 - 1910 |
| Rev. H. L. McCann and Rev. Robert Campbell | 1911 - 1912 |
| Rev. Winfield Randall | 1918 - 1922 |
| Rev. Olin Tracy | 1923 - 1925 |
| Rev. Austin Davis | 1926 - 1927 |
| Rev. Walter Colby | 1927 - 1927 |
| Rev. Allison W. Wentworth | 1927 - 1932 |
| Rev. Walter K. Miller | 1932 - 1936 |
| Rev. Dean Adaire | 1939 - 1941 |
| Rev. Ringdahl | 1942 - 1942 |
| Pastor Booth | 1943 - 1943 |
| Associate Pastor Roger Horton | 1948 - 1949 |
| Rev. Orville Lozier and Rev. Peterson | 1949 - 1949 |
| Rev. Fred J. Duplissey | 1950 - 1950 |
| Rev. Pierce | 1952 - 1952 |
| Rev. J. Albert Hammon | 1952 - 1953 |
| Rev. Robert Haldane | 1953 - 1968 |
| Rev. John W. VanderGroef | 1968 - 1970 |
| Rev. A. Leroy Tyson | 1970 - 1976 |
| Rev. Ralph Hirtle | 1976 - 1980 |
| Pastor David Parker | 1980 - 1986 |
| Rev. Mark E. Rustin | 1987 - |